SimHistory.org
Live Debate · Teacher's guide

The Four Quarter Debate

A whole-class debate played like a football game. Two sides; a side scores only on offense, when its argument stands up to the other side's rebuttal. Every student has a position, and the speaker has a team of researchers behind them.

1–3 periods1 to 3 quarters; Save game between periods
Whole classtwo sides of up to 22; every student speaks or asks at least once
Freethe New Deal debate is the free sample; other topics are Teacher Plus

Positions

Speakers

  • Captain gives the opening and runs the Earpiece: teammates send ideas to the Captain, who forwards the best to the speaker.
  • Offense: Quarterback, Running Back, Wide Receiver present Arguments 1–3. Defense: Linebacker, Cornerback, Safety rebut the other side's arguments. The Kicker gives the conclusion.

Booth Reviewers

  • One or two per side. They check the other side's sources, numbers and quotes.
  • To throw a challenge flag they attach proof from their notebook. You rule. Two per half; a failed challenge costs a timeout.

Sideline Reporters (the Press)

  • Sideline Reporters ask and answer questions in each Interview ("I have a question" puts them in your queue).
  • Everyone researches live: a notebook for links, quotes and pictures, and team chat to send ideas to the speaker.

Running the debate

  1. Before1–2 days
    • Assign the topic and sides. Students join the game the day you start prep: they take roles, fill in their prep sheet and start their notebook. Prep is saved on the student's Chromebook (and in a file they can download for a shared device).
    • Give out the free printables if you like: the individual prep sheet, the group prep sheet and the role sheet.
  2. Pre-Game Show10 minutes
    • Open the projector in its own window. Click Start. Each Captain gives the opening; their prepared text is on the big screen behind them.
  3. Each quarterabout 25 minutes
    • Kickoff → Argument → Interview (the other side's Press ask) → Commercial Break (research and coaching) → Rebuttal → your call. Then the turnover, and the same for the other side.
    • At the call: tick what the offense did and what the rebuttal knocked out, add flags, and make the call. Share your notes on the projector. The ball moves. Practice scoring first.
  4. 4th Quarter10 minutes
    • Each side's conclusion. One that answers an earlier rebuttal is a two-point conversion.
  5. After-Game Show10–15 minutes
    • The replay review: every drive with your notes. Reopen any call. A tie? Pick a winner on the whole game, or go to Overtime: each side nominates a player to answer one of your critiques.
    • Students write their "game film" reflection and download their Game Replay PDF (certificate, prep, notes, notebook, messages) to attach to your Google Classroom assignment. You download the results file: every student's name, notes, chats and stats.

Chat and safety. Team chat is seen only by that side and you. Blocked words never reach the team; you get a flag with the student's name. Pause chat or mute a student any time. Privacy. Students type their name on their own device, where it's locked so only your screen can read it. Notes and chats pass through the live server, which stores nothing; they're kept only on your computer.

First time? Try it side by side, then practice making calls.